After digging around the recesses of my memory, I remembered another hard trophy that might just be harder than the ones I've mentioned.
A God Is Born trophy from Catherine. Trying to beat Axis Mundi stage in the Babel tower was one of the most frustrating experiences I've ever had. The blocks falling are randomized and it's pure skill and luck to make it to the top. I thought I was pretty good at the game, but the wrong blocks falling can ruin your whole climb. I came very close to breaking my controller attempting this one.
Yea I hated inFAMOUS for that. inFAMOUS 2 made it easier with the power to see them close or on the map. But the worse, Im currently doing is, Platinum in Mass Effect 2, beat the game on the highest difficulty. Thats just not freaking right, even with the second play thru on the level below that.